| What
is Moissanite?
Moissanite
is a mineral that was first discovered in fragments of
the meteorite at Diablo Canyon or Meteor Crater in
Arizona. As a diamond
simulant, artificial Moissanite is
very hard to differentiate from diamonds and can fool
many gemologists. It does have many similarities. It is
very hard at 9.25 on the Mohs scale (diamond is 10) and it is highly
refractive with an index of refraction of 2.6 - 2.7
(diamond's RI is slightly lower at 2.42). Most
important, Moissanite and diamond are thermally
conductive unlike other diamond simulants and
unfortunately it is this property that is used as the
test for the authenticity of real diamonds. Differences
however are clear and other tests can be used to
differentiate the two. First of all, Moissanite is
hexagonal, not isometric and therefore it is doubly
refractive unlike a diamond. A close look at Moissanite
gemstones should show double facet edges whereas a diamond's cut edges are singular in appearance. Also
natural flaws are absent in Moissanite replaced instead
by tiny, unnatural, white, ribbon-like structures that
are a result of the growing process.
In the
color category, both Moissanite and Diamond can be found
in a variety of colors/tints. Truly colorless gemstones
(GIA Diamond Color Grade of D-F) can only be had in
Diamond. Diamond can vary from clear to tints in the
pale yellow to brown spectrum. Moissanite always carries
tints in off white to very pale yellow to a greenish
hue. In
practical terms, as a solitaire a good quality
Moissanite looks like a colorless diamond, but compare
it side-by-side to a colorless diamond and the
difference is detectable. Moissanite is shaped and
faceted similar to a diamond.
Moissanite
usually has a yellowish tint. It is a silicon carbide
composition. Upon close examination, moissanite is
usually identifiable. This is because silicon carbide,
in the manufacturing process becomes doubly refractive.
The double refractive index diminishes the illusion of
being a natural diamond. The cost of this stone is $ 365
per carat.
Here are two quotes from an
article at www.professionaljeweler.com. Forrest avoids
comparisons with diamond when selling colorless
synthetic moissanite. "There is no comparison to
diamond," he says. "We do not see or sell it
as a diamond
simulant." "Any gemologist who
looks carefully at moissanite and has trouble making the
separation between it and diamond should consider doing
something else," he says. Jewelers of any caliber
who were fooled were fooled because they became too
complacent on relying on their diamond testers instead
of using their eyes. The older style diamond testers
would test false positives on both colorless sapphire
and moissanite. However, diamond testers have since
evolved and will no longer test positive on moissanite
(so if you have moissanite, don't get too confident
about your gem testing like a diamond.
Moissanite
Qualities
Moissanite
gemstones rival diamond, ruby, emerald, and other fine
gemstones in their brilliance, fire, luster, and
incredible hardness, as illustrated in the following
Comparison Chart:
| |
Refractive
Index (Brilliance) |
Dispersion
(Fire) |
Luster
Index |
Mohs
Hardness |
Toughness |
Specific
Gravity |
| Moissanite |
2.65-2.69 |
0.104 |
20.4% |
9.25 |
Excellent |
3.21 |
| Diamond |
2.42 |
0.044 |
17.2% |
10 |
Good* |
3.52 |
| Ruby |
1.77 |
0.018 |
7.4% |
9 |
Excellent** |
4.00 |
| Sapphire |
1.77 |
0.018 |
7.4% |
9 |
Excellent** |
4.00 |
| Emerald |
1.58 |
0.014 |
4.8% |
7.5 |
Good-Poor** |
2.72 |
| *
In cleavage direction, otherwise excellent |
**
Except twinned stones |
Source:
Charles & Colvard |
The
Mohs Scale
Source:
Kingzett's Chemical Encyclopedia
The Mohs
Scale is used to determine the hardness of solids,
especially minerals. It is named after the German
mineralogist Friedrich Mohs. As indicated in the chart
above, moissanite has a Mohs Hardness rating of 9.25.
The scale reads as follows, with the hardness and
mineral given from softest to hardest:
| 1 |
Talc:
easily scratched by the fingernail |
| 2 |
Gypsum:
just scratched by the fingernail |
| 3 |
Calcite:
scratches and is scratched by a copper coin |
| 4 |
Fluorite:
not scratched by a copper coin and does not
scratch glass |
| 5 |
Apatite:
just scratches glass and is easily scratched by
a knife |
| 6 |
Orthoclase:
easily scratches glass and is just scratched by
a file |
| 7 |
Quartz
(Amethyst, Citrine, Tiger's Eye and Aventurine):
not scratched by a file |
| 8 |
Topaz |
| 9 |
Corundum
(Sapphires & Rubies) |
| 10 |
Diamond:
cuts glass |
Chemical
Hardness
Perhaps
you've wondered "Why is a diamond so hard?"
Diamonds are a naturally occurring mineral, one of two
crystalline forms of the element Carbon. Chemically,
diamonds are pure carbon crystals, and each carbon atom
is held tightly by four bonds to other carbon atoms
nearby. Diamonds are the hardest naturally occurring
substance known because of the strength of these bonds.
You may have heard about the strength of carbon fibers
-- carbon fibers have incredible strength for the same
reason.
Why is
silicon carbine (SiC) nearly as hard? Silicon carbine
relies on carbon bonds as well for its strength. Silicon
carbide is the third hardest compound known to mankind.
In addition, the physical and electronic properties of
SiC make it the foremost semiconductor material for
short wavelength optoelectronic, high temperature,
radiation resistant, and high-power/high-frequency
electronic devices (hence Cree's initial interest in
it). Moissanite is created with silicon and carbon,
through a combination of pressure and heat.
|